Working a denied claim cost providers $57.23 per claim in 2023, according to Premier's survey of 280 hospitals in 23 states. That is up 30.5% from $43.84 in 2022, and it sets a floor for any appeal: a claim worth less than about $83 loses money even when it is overturned.

The figure comes from hospitals, not small practices. Practice-level appeal costs are not published by a named source, so the Premier number is the best public yardstick for the cost side of the decision.

What Premier measured

Premier Inc. published its analysis on February 24, 2025. It surveyed 280 hospitals that hold more than 48,000 acute care beds. The survey ran from August 8, 2024 to February 4, 2025 and covered claims from calendar year 2023. Premier weighted the results by acute bed capacity.

Premier reported a denial rate of nearly 15% of claims and an administrative cost of $57.23 per denied claim. It applied those two figures to about 3 billion claims that U.S. health insurers process each year. The math runs in a straight line: 3 billion claims times 0.15 gives 450 million denials, and 450 million times $57.23 gives $25.7 billion.

That total was up 23% from $19.7 billion the year before. HFMA's January 30, 2026 article by Jeni Williams repeats the cost figure and rounds the total to $25 billion.

Measure20222023
Cost per denied claim$43.84$57.23
Total provider cost$19.7 billion$25.7 billion
Claims needing prior authorization17%More than 20%

Source: Premier Inc., February 24, 2025. Base: 280 hospitals surveyed; 2023 claims year.

Why each claim costs so much

Labor makes up 90% of provider claims processing expense, according to a Health Affairs Scholar article that Premier cites. A denied claim needs a person to read the denial, pull the chart, write the letter and track the reply. No software step removes that time at most practices.

The calendar adds to the cost. Premier found providers went through an average of three review rounds with insurers, and each round took 45 to 60 days. Three rounds therefore run 135 to 180 days from first denial to last answer, and the claim sits in accounts receivable the whole time.

Prior authorization feeds the volume. Premier reports that prior authorization applied to more than 20% of claims in 2023, up from 17% in 2022. In Medicare Advantage it applied to 30.5% of claims, up from 25%.

Premier also cites a MedCity News survey of 200 providers. Every respondent said staffing shortages hurt the accuracy of claim submission, and 83% said shortages slow follow-up on late payments.

How much of that money comes back

Premier says about 70% of denials are overturned and paid. Its methodology page uses a more exact share of 68.6%. Applied to the $25.7 billion, that share gives the "nearly $18 billion" Premier calls potentially unnecessary, because those claims were payable from the start.

Take the lower rate of 68.6% and the $57.23 cost. The expected return on a claim of any size is 0.686 times its value. That return covers $57.23 once the claim is worth $83.43 or more. This is simple arithmetic on Premier's averages, not a Premier finding, and a practice with a different cost per appeal will land on a different number.

Kodiak Solutions tracks how often claims are denied in the first place. As reported by HFMA, the initial denial rate for hospitals and physicians was 11.65% in 2025 through November, against 11.41% in 2024. Denials tied to prior authorization and precertification rose from 1.46% to 1.56% over the same span.

What lowers the cost of an appeal

The HFMA article gives four examples from named organizations. They are small, self-reported results, and none comes from a controlled study.

Cutting letter time from 15 minutes to 8 to 10 minutes removes 33% to 47% of the writing time. That is the labor line Premier says drives the cost, so it is where a per-claim figure can move.

The 2026 picture: fewer denials, more takebacks

Kodiak Solutions published a September 15, 2026 analysis of the first half of 2026 against the first half of 2025. It draws on claims from more than 2,300 hospitals and 375,000 physicians. Commercial initial denial rates fell. Commercial final denial rates rose 9.1% to 2.89% of accounts receivable.

Measure, share of accounts receivableH1 2025H1 2026
Insurer takebacks1.38%1.57%
Provider recoveries after payment2.48%2.21%
Commercial final denial rateNot stated2.89%
Commercial takebacksNot stated2.25%

Source: Kodiak Solutions, September 15, 2026. Base: claims from more than 2,300 hospitals and 375,000 physicians.

Takebacks rose 13.8% and recoveries fell 12.2%. Commercial takebacks rose 12% to 2.25% of accounts receivable. Kodiak says the takeback trend held across every payer and patient setting it analyzed. Fewer first-pass denials did not translate into more cash in that period.

Sources

Talk to us

Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.

Book a demo