The HHS Office of Inspector General flagged 12.9% of Medicare virtual check-in claim lines, 173,287 of 1,341,652, as potential improper payments in an audit issued April 23, 2026. It flagged another 1.7% of e-visit claim lines, 10,237 of 600,235, for the same reason.

The flagged payments total $2,262,325 across 183,524 claim lines. OIG says the audit could not confirm that any line was wrong, because it did not review medical records. It used the diagnosis code and the date of service to find lines that looked like repeat billing for one problem. Medicare paid $24,151,327 on the 1,941,887 lines in the audit pool, so the flagged lines equal 9.4% of the dollars.

What the OIG audit covered

OIG audit A-05-23-00001 examined Medicare Part B claim lines with dates of service from January 1, 2019, through December 31, 2022. The audit work ran from January 2023 through October 2025. The report was posted on April 28, 2026.

The audit covered $12,479,542 paid on 1,341,652 virtual check-in lines and $11,671,785 paid on 600,235 e-visit lines. The table shows how much of each pool OIG flagged.

ServiceLines auditedDollars paidLines flaggedDollars flaggedShare of linesShare of dollars
Virtual check-ins (G2010, G2012)1,341,652$12,479,542173,287$1,964,12512.9%15.7%
E-visits (99421 to 99423)600,235$11,671,78510,237$298,2001.7%2.6%
Both services1,941,887$24,151,327183,524$2,262,3259.5%9.4%

Source: HHS OIG, report A-05-23-00001, April 2026. The share columns are calculated from OIG's totals.

The virtual check-in rule that triggered the flags

A virtual check-in is a brief remote contact with an established patient. Medicare pays for it only when it does not come from a related office visit in the previous 7 days and does not lead to a visit within the next 24 hours, or the soonest available appointment. Providers bill G2010 for a recorded video or image and G2012 for a 5 to 10 minute medical discussion. CMS replaced G2012 with CPT 98016 on January 1, 2025, and the new code has the same descriptor.

OIG flagged 173,287 check-in lines tied to 66,899 patients. Each line fell within 7 days after, or 24 hours before, an office visit that carried the same diagnosis code. That is about 2.6 flagged lines per patient.

OIG gave a worked example. A provider billed a visit for diagnosis E78.5 and Medicare paid $42.52. Two check-ins with the same diagnosis followed on the next two business days at $10.43 each. Billing only the visit would have paid $42.52, not $63.38, a $20.86 gap. The average flagged check-in line was paid $11.33.

Modifiers on the matching visits

Every one of the 173,287 flagged check-in lines had a matching office visit line. Of those visit lines, 120,316 (69.4%) carried a payment modifier. Modifier 25, which marks a separately identifiable service, appeared on 30,743 lines (17.7%). Telehealth modifiers 95 or GT appeared on the other 89,573 lines (51.7%).

Modifier 25 matters because it lets a visit line pass the automated edits in Medicare's Common Working File. OIG tied $337,033 of the flagged check-in payments, 17.2% of the $1,964,125 total, to visits billed that way.

The second example shows how that works. A visit billed with modifier 25 was paid $45.49, and a same-day check-in with the same diagnosis was paid $11.58. Over four visits, Medicare paid $228.28 where the visit payments alone were $181.96, a $46.32 difference. OIG did not decide which service should have been billed. It also did not test whether the visits themselves met Medicare rules.

E-visit billing over a 7-day window

E-visits are patient-initiated portal messages that need a clinical decision. Practices report them with one code for the total time over 7 days: 99421 for 5 to 10 minutes, 99422 for 11 to 20 minutes, and 99423 for 21 minutes or more. OIG flagged 10,237 lines for 6,809 patients, an average of 1.5 lines per patient. The payments came to $298,200, or $29.13 per line.

These lines appeared when a practice billed two or more e-visit codes within 7 days for the same patient and diagnosis. In OIG's example, three e-visits ran on January 29, 30 and 31, 2022. They were billed as 99423, 99422 and 99421 and paid $71.55. One code for the combined time, 99423, would have paid $36.99, a $34.56 difference.

What CMS said and what comes next

OIG made 3 recommendations. The first is system edits that flag same-diagnosis check-ins and e-visits for review, and reject claims that bill a check-in and a visit together. OIG estimated those edits could have saved up to $2.3 million during the audit period. The second is clearer code descriptions. The third is more provider education.

CMS agreed with 2 of the 3. It disagreed with the code description change and said it prefers subregulatory guidance. OIG kept its position, because guidance is not legally binding. CMS also said it has already added edits. OIG listed all three recommendations as open, with CMS updates due March 18, 2027 and May 12, 2027.

A practice that bills these codes can run its own check against the same rules. Pull check-in and e-visit lines from the last 12 months and match each to office visits for the same patient. Look for the same diagnosis within 7 days, or within 24 hours before a visit. Review any visit with modifier 25 that sits near a check-in. Group e-visits by patient and 7-day window and confirm each window carries one code. OIG matched on diagnosis codes alone, so a practice with a documented reason for a separate contact can show it in the chart.

Sources

Talk to us

Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.

Book a demo