About 1.2% of active non-pediatric physicians had opted out of Medicare as of November 2024, or 12,244 physicians, according to KFF. CMS's September 2026 opt-out file now lists 58,286 clinicians of all types, up 83.3% from 31,800 in the November 2023 file.
Most of that growth comes from counselors and therapists. Take out mental health counselors and marriage and family therapists and the list still rose 36.3%, from 31,788 to 43,322 clinicians. This post uses the CMS monthly Opt Out Affidavits files and the KFF brief built on the same data.
How many clinicians are on the CMS opt-out list?
CMS publishes the list monthly. Counting each National Provider Identifier once, the file held 31,800 clinicians in November 2023, 47,439 in November 2024, 51,857 in September 2025 and 58,286 in September 2026. The count rose 49.2% from November 2023 to November 2024, 9.3% to September 2025, and 12.4% to September 2026. The September 2026 file carries a last-updated date of October 21, 2026.
| CMS file | Unique clinicians | Mental health counselors and family therapists | All other clinicians |
|---|---|---|---|
| November 2023 | 31,800 | 12 | 31,788 |
| November 2024 | 47,439 | 10,667 | 36,772 |
| September 2025 | 51,857 | 12,997 | 38,860 |
| September 2026 | 58,286 | 14,964 | 43,322 |
Source: CMS Opt Out Affidavits monthly files, unique NPIs counted by the author. Counselors and family therapists were almost absent from the November 2023 file.
Four behavioral health groups lead the September 2026 file: mental health counselors at 8,020, clinical psychologists at 7,952, clinical social workers at 7,662 and marriage and family therapists at 6,948. Psychiatry follows with 5,011.
The list is not limited to physicians. It also holds psychologists, social workers, dentists, oral surgeons, nurse practitioners and physician assistants. KFF counted 4,474 clinicians with doctorate degrees, such as oral surgeons, podiatrists and optometrists, outside its physician total. Oral surgeons made up 93.9% of that group.
Which specialties opt out most?
KFF found psychiatry had the highest opt-out rate in November 2024, at 8.1% of active psychiatrists. Plastic and reconstructive surgery followed at 4.5%, and neurology at 3.2%. Eleven of the 26 specialty groups in the KFF analysis had rates of 0.5% or lower. Emergency medicine, oncology and radiology were each at 0.1%.
By share of all opt-out physicians, KFF put psychiatry at 39.0%, family medicine at 21.5%, internal medicine at 13.0% and obstetrics and gynecology at 5.9%.
The CMS files show which of these groups grew fastest. Nurse practitioners nearly doubled in 34 months.
| Specialty | November 2023 | September 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nurse practitioner | 1,510 | 2,979 | +97.3% |
| Physician assistant | 403 | 717 | +77.9% |
| Family practice | 2,106 | 2,937 | +39.5% |
| Internal medicine | 1,306 | 1,792 | +37.2% |
| Orthopedic surgery | 291 | 370 | +27.1% |
| Plastic and reconstructive surgery | 353 | 439 | +24.4% |
| Dermatology | 216 | 267 | +23.6% |
| Obstetrics and gynecology | 655 | 772 | +17.9% |
| Psychiatry | 4,488 | 5,011 | +11.7% |
Source: CMS Opt Out Affidavits files for November 2023 and September 2026, unique NPIs counted by the author.
In raw numbers, nurse practitioners added 1,469 clinicians between the two files, family practice added 831, psychiatry 523 and internal medicine 486. Nurse practitioners now rank second among the groups in the table, ahead of family practice by 42 clinicians.
Psychiatry is still the largest physician group on the list, with 5,011 clinicians, but it grew the slowest of the nine groups shown.
Where do opt-out clinicians practice?
In the September 2026 CMS file, California has the most opt-out clinicians with 11,110. New York has 4,915, Texas 3,607, Washington 2,897, Florida 2,873 and Massachusetts 2,222. These are counts of all clinician types, not rates, so they do not compare directly with KFF's physician rates below.
Rates give a cleaner view. In KFF's November 2024 analysis, the highest physician opt-out rates were in the District of Columbia at 2.9%, Alaska at 2.8%, Colorado at 2.3% and Idaho at 2.2%. Forty-seven states were under 2%. Twelve states were at 0.5% or lower, among them Ohio, Iowa, Kentucky and Wisconsin.
When did current opt-out affidavits start?
Each row in the CMS file carries an effective date and an end date. In the September 2026 file, end dates run from October 1, 2026 to January 1, 2029. Counting clinicians by effective year, 15,618 have a 2024 start date, 6,714 have a 2025 start date and 5,429 have a 2026 start date. Start dates as old as 2012 remain on the list, with 801 clinicians carrying that year.
The context for these numbers is a high participation rate. KFF cites MedPAC's March 2024 report that 98% of non-pediatric physicians participate in Medicare. KFF also notes that average Medicare physician payments fell 2.93% on January 1, 2025, and that Part B made up 49% of total Medicare benefit spending in 2024.
What should practice managers check in the file?
Each CMS row has an Eligible to Order and Refer field. Of the 59,071 rows in the September 2026 file, 30,852 are marked Y and 28,219 are marked N. A billing team that sends referrals, orders or lab work to outside clinicians can match those NPIs against the monthly file.
The file also lets a practice compare its own market. A group in California can count the 11,110 listed clinicians in the state, and a group elsewhere can compare its own state count with the 2.9% rate KFF found in the District of Columbia. KFF flags two limits: it has no county-level or rural opt-out data, and it has no breakdown by physician ownership.
KFF also notes that its denominator includes active physicians who work in research or administration instead of patient care.
Sources
- CMS, Opt Out Affidavits: 2026-09-01, updated October 2026
- CMS, Opt Out Affidavits: 2025-09-01, October 2025
- CMS, Opt Out Affidavits: 2024-11-01, December 2024
- CMS, Opt Out Affidavits: 2023-11-01, December 2023
- KFF, How Many Physicians Have Opted Out of the Medicare Program?, January 17, 2025
Talk to us
Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.